Most of the VRS are controversial
and ball brushing stumps and just touching bails
Whether it's umpires call or a review by pinned batsman
This is maximum in LBW decisions.
Expert feels ball touching breaking wickets bails structure
In hawk eye is OK. Umpires feel it must be Ground Umpires Say..
Both are right but marginal issues errupt ! Both are partially wrong
Then more controversies..!!
I have a humble suggestion
While evaluating Only for LBW things ....
Technology can be modified Further...
In Hawkeye Software if stump size is treamed to 2 cms less
It's height and east west side... Then confusion caused by
Dubious out come can be taken care off by keeping Umpires
Wish, status, judgemental priority, honoured too !
If structure breaks Out... if doesn't Not Out
It should take care of the margin of error concession
Asked & insisted by ground Umpires Lobby !
The size of stumps that should be truncated can be determined after an all experts panel. 2 cms is a before discussion suggestion.
Dr H G Joshi
INDIA
